How do you define “safe”?
The following was posted during a discussion on living car-free in Detroit on bikeforums.net (emphasis ours):
Ahh, the myth that the metro area is all Detroit. I live in a very nice suburb that is quiet and safe. The only reason I feel the need to leave here is just so I can depend less upon a motorized vehicle and more upon my own power. The car culture here is strong and the roads are just not safe for riding everywhere I would like to be able to go.
So which is it? The suburb is safe but the roads are not safe?
From a cyclist perspective, if the roads aren’t safe, your community isn’t safe. Cycling advocates shouldn’t let local governments view safety only from behind a windshield.
But surely suburbs do have lower reported crime rates compared with Detroit. Then again, having a motor vehicle on their horn and passing unsafely is?assault with a deadly weapon, though it’s rarely reported.
It does seem Detroit’s streets are safer for cycling — a conclusion supported by the average yearly bicycle crashes per 100K residents from 2004 through 2009.
Detroit | 16.5 |
St. Clair County | 18.9 |
Oakland County | 19.4 |
Wayne County (without Detroit) | 25.0 |
Macomb County | 26.1 |
Also, Detroit has the lowest bicycle crash rate despite having a highest bike to work rate.
And as for living car-free, it would be tough to beat Detroit’s Corktown neighborhood.
Related Posts
Tags: crash data, Detroit, Macomb County, Oakland County, Safety, St. Clair County, Wayne County
January 23rd, 2010 at 10:49 pm
I think the distinction in the quote needs to be made between “secure” and “safe”. I define security as feeling safe. When I moved to Detroit, some family expressed concern that I wouldn’t be safe. But even if my risk of crime is slightly higher down here and people don’t FEEL as safe, it’s still many times safer than sitting in a car on the highway 10x a week to come down here for work. The suburbs aren’t actually safer, people must just feel more secure there.
January 25th, 2010 at 10:16 am
[…] good stuff from around the network: FABB Blog on the decline in teen drivers. M-Bike.org on the definition of "safe." And Copenhagenize on advertising in a bicycle […]
January 25th, 2010 at 10:32 am
[…] good stuff from around the network: FABB Blog on the decline in teen drivers. M-Bike.org on the definition of "safe." And Copenhagenize on advertising in a bicycle […]
January 25th, 2010 at 11:54 am
[…] about there. More good stuff from around the network: FABB Blog on the decline in teen drivers. M-Bike.org on the definition of "safe." And Copenhagenize on advertising in a bicycle […]
January 25th, 2010 at 12:16 pm
[…] about there. More good stuff from around the network: FABB Blog on the decline in teen drivers. M-Bike.org on the definition of "safe." And Copenhagenize on advertising in a bicycle […]