How do you define “safe”?

The following was posted during a discussion on living car-free in Detroit on bikeforums.net (emphasis ours):

Ahh, the myth that the metro area is all Detroit. I live in a very nice suburb that is quiet and safe. The only reason I feel the need to leave here is just so I can depend less upon a motorized vehicle and more upon my own power. The car culture here is strong and the roads are just not safe for riding everywhere I would like to be able to go.

So which is it? The suburb is safe but the roads are not safe?

From a cyclist perspective, if the roads aren’t safe, your community isn’t safe. Cycling advocates shouldn’t let local governments view safety only from behind a windshield.

But surely suburbs do have lower reported crime rates compared with Detroit. Then again, having a motor vehicle on their horn and passing unsafely is?assault with a deadly weapon, though it’s rarely reported.

It does seem Detroit’s streets are safer for cycling — a conclusion supported by the average yearly bicycle crashes per 100K residents from 2004 through 2009.

Detroit 16.5
St. Clair County 18.9
Oakland County 19.4
Wayne County (without Detroit) 25.0
Macomb County 26.1

Also, Detroit has the lowest bicycle crash rate despite having a highest bike to work rate.

And as for living car-free, it would be tough to beat Detroit’s Corktown neighborhood.

Tags: , , , , , ,

5 Responses to “How do you define “safe”?”

  1. Hannah Says:

    I think the distinction in the quote needs to be made between “secure” and “safe”. I define security as feeling safe. When I moved to Detroit, some family expressed concern that I wouldn’t be safe. But even if my risk of crime is slightly higher down here and people don’t FEEL as safe, it’s still many times safer than sitting in a car on the highway 10x a week to come down here for work. The suburbs aren’t actually safer, people must just feel more secure there.

  2. Streetsblog Capitol Hill » The Urban Core as Regional Economic Indicator Says:

    […] good stuff from around the network: FABB Blog on the decline in teen drivers. M-Bike.org on the definition of "safe." And Copenhagenize on advertising in a bicycle […]

  3. Streetsblog New York City » The Urban Core as Regional Economic Indicator Says:

    […] good stuff from around the network: FABB Blog on the decline in teen drivers. M-Bike.org on the definition of "safe." And Copenhagenize on advertising in a bicycle […]

  4. Streetsblog San Francisco » The Urban Core as Regional Economic Indicator Says:

    […] about there. More good stuff from around the network: FABB Blog on the decline in teen drivers. M-Bike.org on the definition of "safe." And Copenhagenize on advertising in a bicycle […]

  5. Streetsblog Los Angeles » The Urban Core as Regional Economic Indicator Says:

    […] about there. More good stuff from around the network: FABB Blog on the decline in teen drivers. M-Bike.org on the definition of "safe." And Copenhagenize on advertising in a bicycle […]

Leave a Reply